|
1641 |
Irene Murray |
2012-10-01T12:06:12.143 |
Wonderful role for a midwife - not a nurse! |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-01T12:06:39.41 |
Oh, and don't worry Alec, should I be afforded the opportunity of speaking to the Committee, I will make sure that th... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-01T12:36:33.097 |
Bill, you declare that "all measurable chemicals have a safe limit of exposure based upon an 8 hour working day". Wh... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-01T13:29:01.287 |
Alec, what makes you think that carcinogens are different be it they are derived from tobacco smoke, smoke from an op... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-01T14:54:04.393 |
Alec, you should be addressing your concerns to the Health and Safety Executive not me as they have clearly stated th... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-01T15:57:15.727 |
Bill, I apologised for assuming you were a salesman in a post that has not been published. I'll apologise again, and ... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-01T15:58:28.413 |
For anyone who is interested in the truth this is an excellent read Toxic Toxicology by Littlewood & Fennel |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-01T18:15:19.94 |
Finally\r\n\r\nGoogle JTI, Dubai Airports and JCDecaux unveil striking smoking lounge initiative\r\n\r\nProof if any... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-01T19:35:11.553 |
Finally, finally\r\n\r\nAlec, as the HSE, OSHA (USA) and MAK (Germany) operate in parallel, the data presented in Tox... |
|
1611 |
Wendy |
2012-10-01T19:35:54.103 |
Living in the USA. Please realize that the world it watching. |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-01T21:26:57.99 |
Bill's suggested read is not the truth, and is popular with the pro-smoking groups he associates with. For proper, u... |
|
1612 |
Linda Hanratty |
2012-10-01T22:47:37.32 |
My daughter was born in 1971 with a congenital heart defect and is now 41 years old, give our children a chance, a fu... |
|
1663 |
stephen mc killop |
2012-10-02T07:31:07.35 |
when will stop cutting and start investing in our future ? cuts to frountline service and attacks on the sick and dis... |
|
1614 |
Bridget Harris |
2012-10-02T09:07:14.24 |
This is an important issue long overdue for sorting out |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-02T09:34:03.96 |
There are many well ventilated Smokers Lounges in existance, working within the respective country's Occupational Hea... |
|
1655 |
Belinda Cunnison |
2012-10-02T10:49:17.1 |
Alec, what you say about isolating the toxins assumes that the ambient air is clean. But we know that there is ambien... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnson |
2012-10-02T13:10:54.937 |
Bill, why don't you answer my questions? Is it because you don't understand, or is it because a truthful answer woul... |
|
1655 |
Belinda Cunnison |
2012-10-02T23:43:50.343 |
In answer to Alec Johnson, or Johnston, your suggestion to Bill Gibson at 21.26 refers to only one kind of air cleani... |
|
1641 |
Harriet Sophie Wyn-Evans |
2012-10-02T23:46:47.133 |
I lost my first baby in 1997 whilst a student in Dundee due to undiagnosed HG |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-03T16:46:21.817 |
Belinda, you are missing the whole point, and it just shows how poor your understanding of the requirements of EH40 i... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-03T16:52:19.957 |
From the manufacturers - and not a very reassuring assessment of the capability in the real world of pubs and clubs, ... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-03T16:59:01.433 |
More from the manufacturer about the product you are suggesting will protect people from carcinogenic chemicals if yo... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-03T17:03:23.17 |
Final few quotes from the manufacturer. "PCI products are not medical equipment and therefore we do not claim that t... |
|
1655 |
Belinda |
2012-10-03T18:45:13.643 |
Actually Alec I don't believe that the manufacturer specifically excludes tobacco smoke. But give me a link if that i... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-03T18:53:42.83 |
The response to a Freedom of Information Request by Tobacco Control Department, Edinburgh\r\n\r\n We hold no informat... |
|
1655 |
Belinda Cunnison |
2012-10-03T18:54:19.923 |
Actually I don't believe that the manufacturer specifically excludes tobacco smoke. \r\n\r\nIf we exclude everything ... |
|
1655 |
Belinda Cunnison |
2012-10-03T18:54:36.25 |
Nobody said that the machine was medical equipment and who said anything about viruses? \r\n\r\nAs for rules prohibit... |
|
1655 |
Belinda Cunnison |
2012-10-03T19:04:37.693 |
Secondly smoking is a societal phenomenon in which up to one quarter of the population partakes. More in some distric... |
|
1655 |
Dermot Hanway |
2012-10-03T20:13:44.8 |
Why are the majority of signatories not from Scotland? |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-03T20:28:24.85 |
Alec\r\n\r\nPoint of Law ..... Kay Labate v Commission of the European Communities\r\n\r\n |
|
1655 |
Otto Kjaergaard |
2012-10-04T08:10:38.137 |
I am have been frequent traveller to Scotland for many years, I have seen how much damage this ban has done to your p... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-04T09:23:07.443 |
Dermot ... until at least October 2014 Scotland is part of the United Kingdom, therefore many of the signatures that ... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-04T12:51:28.963 |
Dermot, a similarly pertinent question would be why there are so many signatories to the petition from the internatio... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-04T13:00:02.123 |
Bill, your point of law is irrelevant to this. Why are you bringing in irrelevant points when the key issue is that ... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-04T13:02:33.923 |
Belinda, the equipment manufacturer says " "Plasmacluster Ions have no immediate effect on chemicals". You are claimi... |
|
1655 |
Eddie Douthwaite |
2012-10-04T13:06:28.59 |
The comprehensive evidence which will be given to the Petitions Committee by the petitioner will prove the effectiven... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-04T13:53:19.913 |
Belinda says "As for rules prohibiting a carcinogen being released unnecessarily, that is moot." It is only moot in ... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-04T13:56:25.82 |
Eddie, surely it doesn't help your case that Belinda and Bill can't string together any decent evidence that your sup... |
|
1655 |
Belinda Cunnison |
2012-10-04T14:07:11.857 |
It makes absolutely no sense to remove smoke on the grounds of improving air quality as if it is the only pollutant i... |
|
1655 |
Eddie Douthwaite |
2012-10-04T14:32:29.623 |
Alec, As I said, the FULL evidence will be presented to the Petitions Committee for consideration and not in this com... |
|
1655 |
Bill Gibson |
2012-10-04T15:31:58.827 |
For every hospitality venue that is forced to close, politians must accept that there is also loss of sales tax, busi... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-04T16:05:12.2 |
Belinda, you continue to flaunt your ignorance about the requirements of EH40. Firstly your petition states that "Al... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnson |
2012-10-04T17:02:27.2 |
"all in the name of health when as a nation we cannot afford the costs of growing old as it is.\r\nBill Gibson" Smok... |
|
1655 |
brian moore |
2012-10-04T17:18:58.137 |
lets make this land FREE again and fight the tobacco TALIBAN and all the anti people who wish to make our lives as mi... |
|
1655 |
Eddie Douthwaite |
2012-10-04T21:51:17.38 |
Alec, it will be up to the Petitions Committee to make an informed decision on this petition. For someone who has com... |
|
1655 |
Alec Johnston |
2012-10-05T11:57:14.847 |
Eddie, I hope the Petitions Committee are told the truth. Your petition says that "All toxins have safe levels liste... |
|
1641 |
Heather Miranda |
2012-10-05T16:07:41.207 |
Hyperemesis is a horrific illness and so much more needs to be done to care for women going through it. |
|
1641 |
Angela |
2012-10-05T16:39:25.797 |
HG is a terrible condition and has caused hardship in mine and my families lives. There needs to be more specialized ... |
|
1641 |
Margaret O'Hara |
2012-10-05T16:48:21.247 |
The shoddy treatment of women with hyperemesis gravidarum through most of the 20th century until now is nothing short... |
|
1641 |
Amanda McGregor |
2012-10-05T18:19:40.34 |
I have suffered this horredous condition three times and have only one child as a result. It was misunderstood and u... |